Edward Devlin and Alfred Burns Miscarriage Of Justice

Edward Devlin & Alfred Burns - a miscarriage of justice?

Beatrice Alice Rimmer was 54 year old widow who lived alone at 7 Cranborne Road opposite Sefton General Hospital, on Smithdown Road in Liverpool and who was reputed to keep money in her house.

Beatrice had visited her son on the Sunday afternoon and was seen returning to her home that evening. On Monday, August the 20th, 1951, her next door neighbour, Jack Grossman, alerted Alice’s son Thomas to the suspicious scene outside his mothers front door. There was a bottle of milk on the doorstep, delivered around 6a.m., but it was now long after midday.

Alice, as she was known, had not been seen all morning and Mr. Grossman had become concerned about her welfare. Thomas couldn’t get any reply but looking through the letterbox could see his mother lying in a pool of blood. At the back of the house a window had been broken. Alice had been attacked with a cosh and had 15 separate wounds which indicated that she might have been tortured to reveal the whereabouts of her money.

The police initially suspected Thomas of being involved until George McLaughlin, a man serving time for burglary in Liverpool’s Walton prison, gave them a tip off. He told police two Mancunians, 22 year old Edward Devlin and 21 year old Alfred Burns, had admitted the murder to him.

The only forensic evidence was a drop of blood on the coat belonging to one of them, which was not even from the same blood group as Mrs. Rimmer. Devlin and Burns strenuously denied the murder and had an alibi for the night of Sunday the 19th of August - they were breaking into the Sun Blinds Ltd factory in Manchester at the time!

They came to trial at St. George’s Hall in Liverpool before Mr.

Justice Finnemore on 12th of February 1952 and were convicted on the 27th of that month. In court neither behaved well and were critical of the judge and jury. Rose Heilbron defended the pair and told the jury that the evidence against Burns and Devlin was entirely circumstantial - no one had seen them enter or leave the house. It took the jury just 75 minutes to reach their verdict. Asked if they had anything to say before they were sentenced Devlin told the judge.

“My Lord. I would like to stress that it means the police are not infallible and tell lies.”

Their appeal before the Lord Chief Justice and Justices Ormerod and Parker was dismissed on the 31st of March but the Home Secretary, Sir David Maxwell Fife, took the unusual step of appointing Albert Gerrard QC to examine the case and he reported that they were guilty. So, at 9.00 a.m.

on Friday the 25th of April the pair were hanged side by side in Walton prison, by Albert Pierrepoint assisted by Syd Dernley, Robert Leslie Stewart and Harry Smith. Burns weighed 165 lbs. and was given a drop of 6’ 10”, Devlin weighed 158 lbs. and his drop was 7’ 1”. On Sunday the 27th it was reported in the press that both men had confessed to killing Alice. According to Syd Dernley’s memoirs, neither man spoke during the execution.

Recent developments.

In 2018 new evidence has come to light regarding these two men that raises serious doubts about the safety of their conviction which has led to it being referred to the court of appeal.

It appears that Alice Rimmer complained about her son, Thomas, in a letter she wrote to her deceased husband's pension provider. It said : "I am sorry to add that I cannot look for any help or sympathy from my son. I have not dared to tell him about this extra allowance. I have given and given but now firmly resolve not another penny. Money slips like water through his hands and now he is realising what he's done. I do know that if I pass away, he would have a royal time of it for a few months."

This letter provides Thomas Rimmer with a clear motive to kill his mother. Additionally, the broken window he said that he used to gain entry into the property where he found his mother's body, did not leave any fibers of his chunky jacket nor could he replicate gaining entry without leaving any finger marks or fibres in the three attempts he tried to demonstrate why the window was simply broken but untouched.

As of October 2018, the case has not been referred to the Court of Appeal.

Thanks for reading, we provide you the best of history.

more interesting stories and facts below and don't forget to leave your thought in the comment section

Comments

THE TERRIBLE STORY OF THE LAST COMMANDER OF ONE GERMAN PANTHER TANK.

On this day in 1945, Americans capture the city of Cologne, Germany. The town had already been shattered by years of aerial raids. Now, as World War II was coming to an end, Germans began to flee before the oncoming American tanks. Yet the commander of one German Panther tank refused to go. Instead, he made a last stand in front of Cologne Cathedral, one of the few buildings to remain mostly intact. The Panther tanks were heavier and tougher than the American Sherman tanks. Indeed, that Panther soon knocked out a pair of M4 Sherman tanks, killing or wounding several of our soldiers. But Americans had another, newer tank: the Pershing. One crew was nearby and swung into action. Its commanding officer hoped to attack the Panther from a side street before the Germans knew what was coming. The move was nearly fatal. Inside the German tank, the crew sensed that something wasn’t right. The tank’s turret was turned so that its muzzle was aimed at the side street. Just then, the Pershing came

THE EXECUTION OF COLONEL HO NGOC CAN BY THE COMMUNIST FIRING SQUAD.

"ARVN Colonel HO NGOC CAN (1940-1975) Ho Ngoc Can was admitted in the ARVN Junior Military Academy when he was 14 years old. After graduation, he served 4 years as an instructor sergeant in the same academy. In 1961, he attended the Officer Candidates Class at the Dong De NCO Academy and was the distinguished graduate of the class in 1962. After commissioned, Can served the Ranger Corps as a platoon leader. He was promoted to captain in 1965, to major in 1968, to lieutenant colonel in 1971, and to full colonel in 1974. He was successfully commanding the 1/33 Battalion (21st Infantry Division), the 15th Regiment (9th Inf. Div.). In 1974, Can was appointed province chief of Chuong Thien Province, Vietnam south area. On April 30, 1975, he refused to surrender to the enemy. Along with his troops, Can was fighting with all his might, holding the provincial headquarters until 11:00 PM on May 1, when his forces were out of ammunition. In the last minutes, he ordered the

The Heroic Story Of Lieutenant Colonel Jay Zeamer, Jr. of Carlisle, Honoring Him For His Extraordinary Actions During WWII.

The Heroic Story Of Lieutenant Colonel Jay Zeamer, Jr. of Carlisle, Honoring Him For His Extraordinary Actions During WWII. U.S. Army Air Forces Lieutenant Colonel Jay Zeamer, Jr. of Carlisle, Pennsylvania, was awarded the Medal of Honor for his extraordinary actions on June 16, 1943, over Buka area, Solomon Islands. In October 1939, Zeamer applied for the Army Air Corps flight training program and was accepted in December. His entrance to the program was deferred until after graduating from M.I.T. in June 1940 with a B.S. in Civil Engineering, specializing in Structural Engineering. Zeamer began elementary flight school training as a flying cadet in the Chicago School of Aeronautics, Glenview, Illinois, where his leadership skills earned him the position of Captain of Cadets of Class 41-B. In March 1941, he received his wings and a commission in the U.S. Army Air Corps after graduating from basic and advanced flight school at Maxwell Field, Alabama. On June 16, 1943, Zeamer

THE TERRIBLE ESCAPE OF WILLIAM DYESS FROM THE JAPANESE PRISONERS OF WAR CAMP.

The Terrible Escape Of , William Dyess From The Japanese Prisoners Of War Camp. On this day in 1943, William Dyess was able to escape from a Japanese prisoner of war camp in the Philippines along with nine other men, and to make his way through the jungle and to a ship that transported him to Australia. Once free, Dyess would be able to reveal to the world the atrocities of the Bataan Death March that had taken place after U.S. and Philippine forces surrendered on April 9, 1942. When the Bataan Peninsula fell to the Japanese, Dyess, as commanding officer, refused to abandon those of his squadron who could not be evacuated. He gave his airplane to another fighter pilot for last bombing run on April 9. Dyess also supervised the evacuation of Philippine Army Colonel Carlos Romulo, a close friend of General Douglas MacArthur, who would survive the war and would later serve as President of the United Nations General Assembly. Dyess was captured by the Japanese on April 9, 1942, north of

THE PAINFUL EXECUTION OF EDITH CAVELL FOR HELP THE ENEMIES EXCAPE SHE IS A BRITISH WAR HEROINE WWII.

Edith Cavell - a British war heroine. Edith Louisa Cavell was born on the 4th of December 1865 at Swardeston, near Norwich, the daughter of a local vicar. Edith trained as a nurse and would become the matron of The Berkendael Medical Institute in Belgium in 1907. She was also active in nurse training there. The first World War broke out in 1914 and at the time Edith was on holiday, visiting her mother in Norfolk. Her family begged her to stay in England but she returned to her job in Brussels. The city would fall to the Germans on the 20th of August 1914. Edith was allowed to remain at her post when the hospital was taken over by The Red Cross. Edith began rescuing and treating injured British and French soldiers and getting them across the border into neutral Holland from where they could return to Britain. She also assisted Belgian civilians. These activities constituted a crime under German Military Law. Paragraph 58 of the German Military Code said: "Will be sente

The Terrible Death Of Captain Ben Salomon The Dentist Of WWII Who Kill 100 Japanese Soldier In His tent.

The Terrible Death Of Captain Ben Salomon The Dentist Of WWII Who Kill 100 Japanese Soldier In His tent. Captain Ben Salomon was a dentist who wound up on Saipan in the middle of one of the largest mass-banzai charges of the entire Pacific War. Before it was over, he killed over 100 Japanese soldiers in defense of his aid station. In 2002, 58 years later, he was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions. ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ “...serving at Saipan, on July 7, 1944, as the Surgeon for the 2nd Battalion, 105th Infantry Regiment, 27th Infantry Division. The battalion was attacked by an overwhelming force estimated between 3,000 and 5,000 Japanese soldiers. It was one of the largest attacks attempted in the Pacific Theater during World War II. The enemy soon penetrated the battalions’ perimeter and inflicted overwhelming casualties. In the first minutes of the attack, approximately 30 wounded soldiers walked, crawled, or were carried into Captain Salomon’s aid station. As the perime

THE HEROIC STORY IF CHOATE HE ENLISTED IN THE ARMY AS A PRIVATE AND SERVED 31MONTJA OVERSEAS...

Clyde Lee Choate of West Frankfort, Illinois, a Staff Sergeant in the U.S. Army, was awarded the Medal of Honor for his extraordinary actions on October 25, 1944, near Bruyères, France. Choate enlisted in the Army as a private and served 31 months overseas in the European Theatre. By October 25, 1944, he was serving as a staff sergeant in Company C, 601st Tank Destroyer Battalion. On October 25, near Bruyères in eastern France, his tank destroyer was hit and set on fire in an attack by German forces. He ordered his crew to abandon the destroyer and reach safety but then returned through hostile fire to ensure no one was trapped inside. Seeing a German tank overrunning American infantry soldiers, he single-handedly attacked and destroyed the tank. He was awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions on October 25, 1944. Choate was honorably discharged from the Army in 1946. In 1946, he was elected to the Illinois House of Representatives. After three decades in the legislature, he retire

Honoring Gene Autry "Cowboy Entertainer" For His Services During WWII .

🇺🇲WWII uncovered: Gene Autry: Cowboy, Entertainer and Proud World War II Veteran "When World War II broke out, Gene Autry was determined to join the armed forces and do his part. On July 26, 1942, during a live broadcast of his radio show Melody Ranch and at the Pentagon's request, he was inducted into the Army Air Forces as a Technical Sergeant. Already a private pilot, Gene set out to earn his wings as a Flight Officer. After basic training at the Santa Ana Air Force Base, and serving at Luke Field, Thunderbird Field, and Phoenix Airport, he was eventually accepted for flight training at Love Field in Dallas." "A week after Gene was sworn into the military, the Gene Autry Melody Ranch radio show became the Sergeant Gene Autry radio show on August 2, 1942. The program was part of Gene’s regular duties in the Army Air Forces and still had his music, comedy, and action in a dramatic story but now with a military theme. The songs were patriotic, the comedy based on

Search This Blog